SmartyCard Blog

Learn stuff, earn stuff, blog stuff

SmartyCard’s future

February 25th, 2010 by aaron.burcell

I’m posting a few notes on SmartyCard as a general business update, hoping to clarify recent posts and tweets containing “between-the-lines” comments. I’m going to send out a customer email with this information tomorrow or Monday as well.

Before I share these, I want to say that we’re closing in on our first year of service releases. We’ve enjoyed amazing support from parents, industry experts, press and bloggers, and our initial customers. This has resulted in better-than-expected sampling rates, and despite our less-than-perfect purchase flows, we haven’t been able to stop our fans from buying SmartyCard. We learned a lot along the way, and our business will reflect that learning in 2010 product changes.

First clarification: I’ve had some amazing conversations recently about the future of incentive-based services and devices focusing on reinforcing universal family values, which gives us insights on how to apply our technology as a platform and in shared/partnered offerings. It’s our pleasure to host and lead these conversations with future leaders in children’s health and fitness, like Switch2Health and Hope Lab, as well as leaders in language development, English-as-a-second language for International markets, pre-reading child development, banking/educational savings and diet/nutrition. It seems incentive-based learning for children has many, many applications wherein parents can leverage web properties to reinforce universal values for younger generations. And, if I may augment my previous comments on our ability to influence, we’re excited that our brand and initial service concepts are so respected that entrepreneurs seek out our input, ideas and partnership as they conceive and refine their go-to-market strategies. This is really a testament to the hard work and talent of the folks that built SmartyCard. We have exciting partnerships developing for the future, but for the sake of brevity, I’ll get to the next point of clarification.

Second clarification: SmartyCard is soon initiating some customer-driven changes. The brand itself was built for a business that included a retail and stored-value business. That future direction is very much in doubt. One thing that is not in doubt, is the popularity of physical goods as rewards. We’ll cease providing those rewards options in the near future. Here’s the really important thing that we want to convey with this change: We listen and pay attention to our customers as they use SmartyCard and talk about the value of SmartyCard. And, our customers, for the most part, don’t redeem their points for physical goods. This learning contradicted the field research and customer surveys we internalized while developing SmartyCard in 2008. To make sure this trend wasn’t price sensitivity or a “discovery issue”, we reduced point totals, reduced the overall number of rewards and presented rewards by category. We even promoted more physical goods in our pre-registration pages. Even after we reduced the price on physical rewards so that the points required were at or near list prices, digital goods remained at or above 85% of our reward redemptions. We took the hints.

Third, SmartyCard subscriptions weren’t implemented correctly in 2009: In general, we know that our purchase flows weren’t optimal last year. And, rather than expose our customers to a series of copy changes and page-flow changes, we took the time to learn and understand the underlying issues of how to communicate and architect a rewards-based system that everyone in the family can understand and explain to each other. In the process, we discovered a lot more about how families communicate. We’re going to apply our strengths in email and acquisition competency to change the way SmartyCard is presented and communicated to parents.

We appreciate your patience and ongoing support as we develop these improvements. We’re excited for the future of our business, and the proliferation of incentive-based learning.

SmartyCard in LovetoKnow Kids

February 23rd, 2010 by aaron.burcell

SmartyCard was featured in LovetoKnow Kids homepage today in the Family Friendly Technology Interview. Here’s a link to the story.

4 tips for getting great customer service, 4 things to avoid

February 22nd, 2010 by aaron.burcell

As a part of our 2010 product planning and development process, I’ve been sitting on the front line of SmartyCard support.  The exposure is incredibly valuable.  Most requests are fairly simple, and our customers are very sweet and funny.

We’ve been having a number of issues with the delivery of physical rewards, and we’re likely to discontinue offering those rewards in the near future.  But, here is the really interesting thing that I’m noticing — people that call our phone numbers and leave voicemails are generally unaware of how to facilitate their needs by providing relevant information.  Here are some general customer support tips that should work for anyone calling into a customer support service.

When placing a support call, be prepared to leave a voicemail that includes these simple customer verification hints:

1. A phone number is good to include in a voicemail

2. It’s also good to share your name, along with the correct spelling of your name.

3. If you’re contacting a web service, you probably want to be ready to type or say the username-password combination that you provided in the sign-up process.

4. If you can remember, let support know when they might be able to reach you by the phone.

At SmartyCard, we can pretty much solve anything if we have these bits of information.  We can even solve your support issue without giving you a call back.  I know the above information looks like a “no brainer”, but if you’re in a hurry, or you’re not in front of your PC, it’s very easy to forget these basic bits of information.

You may have noticed that most web services are basing their account creation off of email addresses — even if your login is verified by Facebook Connect login.  At signup, SmartyCard creates a username from your email address.  People tend to forget this, or simply don’t know that it’s important to include an email address when calling or email support.  In some cases, I’ve had 2 and 3 voicemails from agitated customers requesting simple actions like, change of address, or reward delivery check or changes to billing information. Sadly, these agitated customers end up apologizing after we’re able to call or email back.

In these instances, the customer did not leave anything that would help SmartyCard look up their account status. Of course, any customer can make simple account changes by simply logging into their account to  edit their child’s account (two clicks) or change their own account info (two clicks).  But, frequently, paying customers simply pick up the phone and dial the number associated with SmartyCard on their credit card statements, which is actually not the fastest method for getting results.  And, in all honesty, I’m pretty surprised at what I hear in voicemails.  Some customers have recited credit card numbers (in part and in full) and social security numbers.

With my recent support experience, I wanted to share a few tips on what kind of information is generally NOT helpful for support of web-based services, thus wastes everyone’s time:

1. Your credit card number.  We don’t actually handle this information.  In fact, very few premium web services actually handle this information — for the most part, web services have ecommerce billing and transaction partnerships.  Most employees of web service companies, including support agents, aren’t allowed access to these partnered systems because of data security and sensitivity of credit card information.  So, calling and sharing this information in part or in whole is not really helpful to a support agent, and it’s probably not the safest thing to do either.

2. Your social security number.  Generally, you want to keep this number private and not repeat it or put it into any kind electronic message.

3. Information about your children.  Your children have created usernames with SmartyCard, and you can review those by logging into SmartyCard or referencing system notifications (emails) from SmartyCard.  We’re happy if you just want to refer to your kid as “username”. That’s really all we need.

4. Email or transaction numbers related to a specific system notifications or transactions just don’t help us.

5. BONUS: Physical addresses are generally useless, unless you’re calling about a delivery.

Final thought on how to get satisfaction quickly: Customers are generally unaware of how a web service information hierarchy is built and the way customer databases are structured, so here’s a quick way to quickly know which bit your personal information is the key piece when initiating a support interaction.  User account information  — usually usernames, or in some rare instances user numbers — are the key to getting service quickly.  The support people on the other end of the phone or email/web form need that information first to look up the rest of your information.

For the customer the way to think about support is to always remember your primary use of the service you’re contacting.  If I call my voice or sms provider, the first thing they ask me to do is verify my phone number and my identity, because they’re a phone service.  When I call my bank, the first thing they ask me for is my bank account number and then they ask for the last four digits of my tax payer ID, because they’re a bank.  If you’re calling or emailing a web service — especially one that communicates via email, be ready to provide your email address.   If you’re calling your insurance company, you’ll need your policy or group number, followed by your social security number to help verify your ID.  I think you get the picture.

Is SmartyCard working with schools? What about publishers?

February 5th, 2010 by aaron.burcell

We get this question a lot — “How are schools utilizing SmartyCard”? Immediately after we launched at DEMO 09, Larry Magid and Robin Raskin asked us about our school channel efforts, and the questions haven’t stopped since then. Til now, the answer was pretty easy: Individual teachers and parents have been recommending SmartyCard. The recommendations have come in many forms — public statements (I’ve added to our site), blog posts, tweets. I even have a parent flyer from a Los Altos, California primary school, which included a print-out of our home page with endorsements and recommendations scrawled on the page.

This kind of community support is heartwarming. We’ve put a lot of effort into making something that kids, parents and teachers adore. You can’t imagine how hard it is to make this kind of product… maybe you can, but you get my point. We were very proud when a creative teacher in Orange County CA inquired about buying SmartyCard for a class of 16 students this past summer. But, lately, I’ve started to see some charter schools and private schools add SmartyCard to their recommended supplemental education programs. And, today, I saw a blog quote the education executive at Universal Companies, a community development company focused on revitalizing urban American cities.

Here is the quote:
Vice President of Education Lauryn Douthit said school renewals fits Universal’s mission of urban revitalization. She said its instructional models, including its standardized homework program, teaching resource guides, and “smartycard” test preparation, could aid school transformation.

This was good to see.  SmartyCard’s value in test prep is starting to be understood within the broader educational community.  And, because schools are starting to take a programmatic approach to utilizing SmartyCard, naturally I’m seeing a new round of media check-ins with elevated interest in how SmartyCard intends to work with educational text publishers.

I can’t lie. We have had several conversations with publishers, including all of the usual suspects here in America, but as far away as Spain and Hong Kong as well. Standardized test prep, homework, in-school test-prep, integration of publisher characters and story-lines — everything is on the table. Ultimately, if you have ample content, the scope and scale of this business is massive. We’d like to be there now. I’d like to tell you we’re doing something definitive. But, that’s just not true.

The good news is that while we talk with publishers, we’re going to help any school effort we can, noting that we’re *just a startup*.

SmartyCard influencing other kids products

February 2nd, 2010 by aaron.burcell

Back in November when SmartyCard won Gold in Children’s Products category from National Parenting Publications Awards, our VP of Creative,  Adrienne Allen noted in passing that our site was going to get a lot of imitation. I agreed. Neither one of us was felt this was a bad thing, but we just knew that before long everything from our rewards model to email marketing to our site design and layout would be imitated in some way.  At the time, the only other thing that looked a little bit like SmartyCard was SmaryPig. Recently, a customer sent me an email pointing me to SmartyRents as an example of a company imitating our branding. I guess I can see the similarities, but I truly don’t know the artistic intent at SmartyRents. I kind of like their business idea — sorta SmartyCard, sorta NetFlix.

Yesterday, I was flipping through my SmartyCard search feeds and I came across a comparison between SmartyCard and Switch-to-health (S2H.com) in Springwise, a publication that has covered SmartyCard in the past. S2H has a simple enough call to action: Be Active, Get Rewards.  I love the site, the work with real professional athletes and I think young boys will love it too.  The rewards model works for us, I hope it works for S2H.  I’m not just a fan of the rewards model. I am a former college and professional athlete, and I really believe that sports can have a really powerful impact on the health and well being of children. 

S2H felt familiar when I looked closer.  One of our product managers, Lynn Powers, had worked on this idea as a project during graduate school at Stanford.  And, I’ve gotten to know the really smart and energetic folks over at Hope Lab quite a bit, and the gDitty and Ruckus Nation projects look very similar to S2H’s device and incentive concepts.  It looks like both ideas were developed independently, and while I believe that most innovation is truly new-idea-meets-evolved-existing-idea, it’s very cool to see both of these companies developing kids products that will help families stay fit. I’m looking for ways to work with these companies — there’s no reason why fitness and smarts shouldn’t be common goals for everyone.

If you know of other incentive/reward-based systems for children, send me your comments @SmartyCard on twitter.

Might Brands profiles SmartyCard

January 20th, 2010 by aaron.burcell

SmartyCard was the subject of a very interesting social media blog today. Check out Might Brand’s blog here. I know most of our fans (customers and educators) aren’t that interested in the internal operations of our business, but it might make you feel good to know about our “high touch” operating philosophy. Enjoy.

Someone is going to win 100,000 SmartyCard points!

January 11th, 2010 by aaron.burcell

Our good friends over at Dr. Moz are working on a very special “drawing” and participants need to enter no later than January 16th, 5pm pacific.

As we start 2010, I’m considering two really big product changes with the potential to impact the future of SmartyCard’s business. I want to ask you (our customers and supporters) two key questions to help guide our business. And, if you feel passionate one way or the other, please share your thoughts through email (customerservice@smartycard.com) or via a public or direct message in Twitter (@SmartyCard). For Twitter pros, please make sure to use a tag or hash-mark (#SmartyCard) so that all of the interested parties can follow.

Okay, here are the big questions for you:
1. The overwhelming majority of rewards that kids want (SmartyCard WishList) and redeem (SmartyCard Rewards) are virtual rewards, games, down-loadable media and virtual goods. Having physical goods in our rewards seems to be a popular idea when I conduct research, but maybe it’s not as popular with our real customer base. I’d love your thoughts on potentially dropping or removing physical goods as rewards.

2. If you’ve been following the @SmartyCard twitter stream lately, you know that I’ve been following the rapid rise of smart phone penetration in the tween market. With Nintendo DS and PSPs already selling tens-of-millions annually, so called “smart phones” are an increasingly attractive environment for SmartyCard. And, not just because parents buy and download games for their children to play. Today, I learned that Pamlico school district in North Carolina is purchasing 130+ iTouches to help teach math and language arts in primary schools. I’d love to know if SmartyCard on an iPhone or iTouch is an attractive application idea for you and your family.

As always, thanks for your support. And, to all of those parenting bloggers who have recently reviewed SmartyCard — thanks so much for your ongoing support.

Thanks for a terrific 2009!

December 31st, 2009 by aaron.burcell

At the close of the year, the folks here at Gazillion and SmartyCard are thankful for the support of our SmartyCard customers. Our mission to provide American families with fun and interactive learning-based games has enjoyed tremendous support from partners, press, kids and parents. And, over the last few weeks I’ve been fortunate to have greater access and interaction with our customers through our customer support email channel.

Here are some of the interesting things SmartyCard customers are telling me:

· Some of our biology content isn’t quite leveled correctly in the higher grades. We can work on that – thanks for the feedback.

· Because some kids work at a faster pace, some of our customers have requested a higher-priced subscription with more points. We will work on providing that optional subscription price for the future. However, please know that you can top off your little smarty’s account with a direct purchase. Simply login as a parent and select “add points”.

A few updates regarding SmartyCard site and services:

· SmartyCard recently discontinued our phone support because the phone didn’t ring for several months. Seriously, we started to wonder if that phone line even worked, so we’re adapting to our customers’ preferences and focusing entirely on our web/email support systems.

· We’ve recently added some new rewards from our friends at Hidden City Games – stay tuned for more news from that SmartyCard partner.

Finally, stay tuned because there is more exciting news coming from SmartyCard in the coming year. We appreciate your continued support.

Happy New Year!

SmartyCard adds 2nd Grade Content!

November 13th, 2009 by aaron.burcell

Some of you might have noticed that SmartyCard recently added Grade 2 content at SmartyCard.com.  Tis true.  And, the ESRB hearts SmartyCard too.  So too does AlwaysOn.  They recently recognized SmartyCard as “an innovative startup” with the potential to disrupt the education market.  I don’t know about all of this praise, but I will say that we tried really hard this summer to make SmartyCard better for y’all.

Coming up soon, look for a SmartyCard guest blog post at Uniting Kids Blog - http://www.unitingkids.com/default.html.

Crowdsourcing cause marketing ideas

October 14th, 2009 by aaron.burcell

Over the last two months, SmartyCard has been working closely with mom bloggers to source ideas for ads that would run on parent and education oriented blogs.  We have placed some of these ads through media buys and our affiliate program.  The response so far has been fantastic.

In a recent conversation, a tech-oriented blogger suggested she forgo her advertising revenue to benefit an educational cause.  Now I’m looking for an educational cause that might benefit from a joint effort of SmartyCard and parent bloggers.  If you have any ideas for a charity, non-profit or non-governmental organization that is deserving of our $ and efforts, DM me on Twitter at username: SmartyCard.  And, while you’re there, friend me!